The Rising Stars of the Industry: The 2023 Ranking of Premier Mid-market Providers in the Language Services Industry

行业新星:2023年语言服务行业顶级中端市场提供商排名

2023-05-10 13:00 Nimdzi Insights

本文共2559个字,阅读需26分钟

阅读模式 切换至中文

Report by Sarah Hickey. Table of contents What is this report about? If you follow Nimdzi, you know that every year we publish a report called The Nimdzi 100 that ranks the 100 largest language service providers (LSPs) in the world. It’s an important indicator that tells us a great deal about how the global market for language services has developed in the latest financial year, and historical data gathered over the years further allows us to generate trend lines and consider industry growth over a longer period of time. That being said, it is just ONE indicator. And while we know that the top 100 LSPs concentrate just under 20% of total market revenue, we also know that the market is highly fragmented and predominantly made up of companies smaller than USD 10 million. In fact, Nimdzi estimates that there are about 22,500 LSPs with revenues below USD 10 million in the world, plus an additional 650,000 freelancers and one-person businesses (source: https://www.nimdzi.com/how-many-language-service-providers/). So, it seems high time we shine a light on the next in line — the mid-market players, the welterweight division, the ones who have their ears closest to the ground and are keeping this industry afloat by being both large enough to cover a significant range of services and languages and yet niche enough to fill gaps for the big providers when it comes to languages of lesser diffusion, specializations, and access to local talent pools. The “premier mid-market providers” that are the engine this industry runs on. Our ranking is a live document and therefore subject to change. Notes: (FY) fiscal year, figures for the latest financial year (verified with financial reports) (v) verified, data provided by companies (e) estimated revenue, based on extensive industry research The ranking starts with position 101 to highlight that there are another 100 LSPs that are larger in terms of revenue but not listed here. There are six companies (3x2) who share the same ranking position (numbers 105, 126, and 144) because their reported revenues were exactly the same. In these cases, the ranking number was repeated. This means that our ranking lists a total of 59 companies in 56 ranking positions. Several other companies appear to have the same revenue due to currency rounding. However, (aside from the six cases outlined above) the ranking order is accurate considering the second decimal. Methodology In this ranking, we are listing LSPs that did not make the cut for the Nimdzi 100 despite technically being large enough (USD 10 million or more in revenue). Within the Nimdzi 100 report we list these same companies in our “Close, but no cigar” honorary ranking. The ranking further includes LSPs with revenues between USD 3 and 10 million in revenue. We’re listing full company revenue, not just language services revenue. It is impossible to separate these in external sources of information, such as annual reports, press releases, and stock listings, which provide the foundation for our work. We use data from the latest fiscal year for each company. This means the numbers for some companies will not reflect 2022 calendar year revenues. Our definition of language services includes: Translation, localization, transcreation, multilingual desktop publishing (DTP), language quality assurance, linguistic testing, multilingual copywriting, multilingual technical writing, language project management, interpreting, video remote interpreting, telephone interpreting, linguist verification and staffing, media localization, versioning, adaptation, subtitling, voiceover, dubbing, machine translation (MT), training machine translation engines, cultural consulting, data services, and related services. Growth rates are calculated in USD. We use average annual currency conversion rates to US dollars, published by the Internal Revenue Service of the United States for each day of trading in 2022. Most importantly: This ranking does not claim to be a comprehensive list of all LSPs that fall into the USD 3 to 10 million revenue bracket. As our estimate of the number of LSPs in the world shows, we expect that there are at least 2,500 companies that potentially qualify for this ranking. So what this ranking provides is a snapshot and a starting point that honors those LSPs that provided their company data to us in recent Nimdzi surveys. Are you missing from the list? Probably. Well, let’s fix that shall we? We encourage anyone who wants to be part of our rankings to provide their data here. We expect this mid-market ranking to grow significantly in the coming years, so make sure you put your company on the map! The mid-market by the numbers The data show that, when it comes to growth, the year 2022 was a mixed bag for the mid-market players on our ranking. Out of 59 companies, 26 reported various degrees of growth, 25 had negative growth, and revenues remained flat for two companies (six companies did not report their 2021 revenues to allow for growth calculations). This demonstrates a big difference compared to the top 100 largest LSPs, of which 65 reported various degrees of growth and 35 companies had negative growth. When it comes to average growth rate, the premier mid-market providers on our ranking grew 6.4% in 2022 when converted to USD, and 11.6% when calculated in their reporting currencies. This difference is not surprising. For all our global rankings and market sizing estimations, much like other industries, we use the US dollar as a common denominator. As a result, depending on the currency, growth figures for individual companies may vary significantly when calculated in their local currency as compared to results converted to USD. This is always the case, but particularly worth highlighting this year as many world currencies experienced significant devaluations against a strong US dollar in 2022. This had a stronger than usual impact on the growth of individual LSPs and the industry as a whole. There is also a notable difference when we compare these results to the ones for the top 100 largest LSPs in the industry. In this year’s Nimdzi 100 ranking, companies grew 18.7% on average when calculated in US dollars, and 26.5% when calculated in their reporting currencies. That being said, the premier mid-market providers’ average growth rate of 6.4% is still well within a healthy range and close to the compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 7.0% we predicted for the global market as a whole for the coming years in our Nimdzi 100 market analysis. Growth by company size When calculating the growth by company size we opted for the median instead of the average to allow for a more accurate picture. Looking at the results, at first glance it appears that companies with a higher number of employees came out on top. When we look at the graph below, the best growth results were achieved for companies with 250 to 499 employees (43.6%), followed by companies with 500 to 999 people on staff (14.3%). However, this creates a false impression because only two companies on the ranking fall into the 250 to 499 bracket and only one company into the 500 to 999 size class. This is not surprising. Among mid-sized LSPs, the vast majority employ between 25 and 250 people. Any more is a rare sight. So, if we consider the larger portion of companies who operate in these brackets, the results are quite different. In the size classes of 25 to 49, 50 to 99, and 99 to 249 the median growth in 2022 was 0.6%, 2.1%, and -3.4%, respectively. The graph below shows the median growth in 2022 per company size class and compares the results for both the premier mid-market provider ranking of medium-sized LSPs and the Nimdzi 100 ranking of the largest LSPs in the world. The 10 fastest-growing mid-market LSPs Below is a list of the ten fastest-growing mid-market providers on our ranking (growth between 2021 and 2022 revenues in USD). The 10 most productive mid-market LSPs Looking at the productivity of the premier mid-market providers on our ranking, the average revenue per employee in 2022 was about $189,600. For comparison, the average revenue per employee for the top 100 largest LSPs in the world was about $229,300 in 2022. If we consider the average productivity by revenue bracket, then LSPs with revenues below USD 5 million in our mid-market ranking come out on top ($281,964). This is followed by companies with revenues of more than USD 10 million ($207,415). Businesses with revenues between USD 5 and 10 million recorded the lowest average productivity in 2022 ($147,124). Considering company size, six of the 10 most productive companies on our ranking employ fewer than 25 professionals. The remaining four companies have 25 to 49 full-time employees. Location, location, location Growth by geographical distribution To get a better sense of where the biggest growth for the mid-market is coming from by geographical distribution, we have developed a map of the average growth rates of the LSPs on our list by region, based on the country of headquarters. We calculate growth based on revenues expressed in USD, using the average annual exchange rate to US dollar, published by the Internal Revenue Service of the United States for each day of trading in 2022. As already mentioned earlier in the report, this means that, for some regions, currency fluctuations skew the growth picture. If we calculate the average growth of the mid-market LSPs by region in the companies’ local currencies the percentages increase for all regions that do not typically report in USD:14.8% for Asia (vs 3.9.0% in USD), 9.7% for Europe (vs 0.3% in USD), and 1.4% for Oceania (vs -6.4% in USD). LSP distribution by georegion Out of the 59 premier mid-market providers we’ve identified for this ranking, 55.9% are headquartered in Europe and 22.0% in North America. Companies in Asia represent 8.5% of the geographical distribution. Oceania and South America each host 6.8% of the premier mid-market providers on our list. There is no representation from companies based in Africa. Trends and business challenges Although our Nimdzi 100 ranking only lists the 100 largest LSPs in the world, our survey for the Nimdzi 100 is answered by providers of all sizes from around the world. Considering only the responses from LSPs who are listed in this ranking, the following section provides a snapshot of a few key trends and challenges for this segment of the market Key business challenges in 2023 It won’t come as a shock that of the companies who are listed on our premier mid-market provider ranking (and took the survey), more than 90% want to grow their company’s revenue in 2023. After that, the top five business challenges selected are: implementing new processes and technologies (58.1%), developing additional service offerings (55.8%), cutting costs and optimizing processes (53.5%), expanding into new industry verticals (46.5%), and managing price pressure (37.2%). This is quite in line with the results of the full Nimdzi 100 survey that looks at providers of all sizes, with two major distinctions. When we consider the results for providers of all sizes, 47.3% want to improve their brand reception and awareness, whereas in the mid-market segment only 32.6% share this concern. In addition, out of the full survey sample, 42.6% worry about talent retention and acquisition, compared to only 34.9% in the mid-market segment. Impact of global events Although the language services industry is (as we like to say) impervious to crises because there is always a need for communication, there is no denying the fact that individual businesses will nonetheless have ups and downs. Recent shocks to the global economy have triggered a mass reshuffling of the labor market, and we are currently experiencing inflation, currency fluctuations, an energy crisis, and mass layoffs in the tech industry. So, for this year’s Nimdzi 100 survey, we wanted to know how many LSPs are already feeling the impact of these global events and for how it may be impacting their 2023 strategy. Breaking it down to just the replies from LSPs who are part of our premier mid-market provider ranking, here are the results: Are you feeling the impact of the current economic crisis? The results show that more than a third are already feeling the impact of inflation and economic pressure, and another 40% are considering the potential impact as part of their 2023 strategy. Only about 24% have not been impacted at all. Compared with the data collected for LSPs of all sizes, the results differ slightly. Considering the full Nimdzi 100 data set, two out of five companies are already feeling the impact of the current economic crisis, and another 30% are preparing for it in their 2023 strategy, despite not feeling the impact yet. Another 30% report not feeling any impact at all. What are your customers doing? Of course it isn’t just LSPs who are impacted — everyone is, and buyers are no exception. So we asked respondents to our survey what the reactions from their clients have been so far. Considering only the responses from the premier mid-market providers in our ranking, the results show that a majority of companies note that clients have reduced their order volumes (70.0%), and another 23.3% report that clients have reduced the number of languages they are localizing into. In addition, 40.0% state that clients are choosing cheaper, machine-generated solutions instead of human-led services. These results are similar to those of the full dataset of LSPs of all sizes — with one notable distinction: 33.3% of respondents from our premier mid-market provider ranking report that clients have not made any changes to their business with them yet, whereas this is only true for 16% of providers of all sizes. What strategies are you planning to roll out in 2023 to offset rising inflation and economic pressure? Lastly, we wanted to know what strategies companies in our industry are implementing to combat rising inflation and economic pressure in 2023. The results show that the most-reported course of action for LSPs in the premier mid-market provider bracket is increasing the use of machine translation: 50% of companies will be using this cost-saving method. Other popular solutions include increasing prices with clients (35.7%) and reducing office space to save costs (32.1%). In addition to these strategies for increasing revenues and cutting costs, 50.0% of companies report that they will increase salaries for their employees to help compensate for the higher costs of living in the current economic climate. 21.4% are planning to reduce staff and 28.6% want to ask vendors to reduce their rates. These results are again trending in a very similar direction for providers of all sizes in the full Nimdzi 100 dataset. Conclusion What strategies are you planning to roll out in 2023 to offset rising inflation and economic pressure? Two main things. When it comes to trends and business challenges, the results for the medium-sized providers on our ranking are predominantly in line with the results of our full Nimdzi 100 survey that considers providers of all sizes. However, when it comes to growth, there is a more notable gap between the premier mid-market providers and the top 100 largest LSPs. Close to half of the mid-market providers on our ranking reported positive growth in 2022, compared to almost two-thirds of the top 100. And although the average growth for providers in the mid-market segment was still healthy, it was also 12.3 percentage points lower than for the top 100. It is not unreasonable to assume that medium-sized providers were more heavily affected by the economic challenges of 2022, whereas large providers managed to weather the storm better due to a more diversified client portfolio and geographical reach. Overall, it must be acknowledged that this is only a snapshot of the large mid-market segment that makes up the majority of the language services industry. We can expect this ranking to grow in the years to come, which will allow us to paint a more accurate picture over time. Not part of the ranking yet? Make sure to sign up here.
莎拉·希基报道。 目录 这份报告是关于什么的? 如果您关注Nimdzi,您会知道我们每年都会发布一份名为Nimdzi 100的报告,对全球100家最大的语言服务提供商(LSP)进行排名。这是一个重要的指标,它告诉我们很多关于全球语言服务市场在最近一个财政年度的发展情况,多年来收集的历史数据进一步使我们能够生成趋势线,并考虑更长时间内的行业增长。 话虽如此,这只是一个指标。虽然我们知道前100名LSP集中了不到20%的市场总收入,但我们也知道市场高度分散,主要由规模小于1000万美元的公司组成。事实上,Nimdzi估计,世界上大约有22,500家收入低于1000万美元的LSP,外加650,000名自由职业者和一个人的企业(来源:https://www.nimdzi.com/how-many-language-service-providers/)。 因此,现在似乎是我们照亮下一个线的时候了——中端市场参与者,次中量级部门,那些耳朵最贴近地面的人,他们通过足够大以覆盖大量的服务和语言,同时又足够小以填补大型提供商在传播较少的语言、专业化和获得本地人才库方面的空白来保持这个行业的运转。“顶级中端市场提供商”是该行业运行的引擎。 我们的排名是一个实时文档,因此可能会发生变化。 附注: (FY)财政年度,最近一个财政年度的数字(经财务报告核实) ㈤经核实的公司提供的数据 (e)根据广泛的行业研究得出的估计收入 排名从第101位开始,以强调还有另外100家LSP在收入方面更大,但没有在此列出。 有六家公司(3x2)分享相同的排名位置(数字105、126和144),因为它们报告的收入完全相同。在这些情况下,排名数字是重复的。这意味着我们的排名总共列出了56个排名位置中的59家公司。 由于货币四舍五入,其他几家公司似乎也有同样的收入。然而,(除了上面概述的六种情况)考虑到第二位小数,排名顺序是准确的。 方法论 在这个排名中,我们列出了尽管技术上足够大(收入1000万美元或以上)但没有进入Nimdzi 100的LSP。在Nimdzi 100报告中,我们将这些公司列入了我们的“接近,但没有雪茄”荣誉排名。 该排名还包括收入在300万至1000万美元之间的LSP。 我们列出的是公司的全部收入,而不仅仅是语言服务收入。不可能在外部信息来源中分离这些信息,如年度报告、新闻稿和股票列表,这些信息为我们的工作提供了基础。 我们使用每家公司最近一个财政年度的数据。这意味着一些公司的数字将不会反映2022日历年的收入。 我们对语言服务的定义包括:翻译、本地化、翻译创作、多语言桌面出版(DTP)、语言质量保证、语言测试、多语言文案、多语言技术写作、语言项目管理、口译、视频远程口译、电话口译、语言学家验证和人员配备、媒体本地化、版本控制、改编、字幕、画外音、配音、机器翻译(MT)、培训机器翻译引擎、文化咨询、数据服务和相关服务。 增长率以美元计算。 我们使用美国国税局公布的2022年每天交易的美国元平均年货币兑换率。 最重要的是:这个排名并不声称是收入在300万到1000万美元之间的所有LSP的综合列表。正如我们对全球LSP数量的估计所示,我们预计至少有2500家公司有资格获得这一排名。因此,这个排名提供了一个快照和一个起点,以表彰那些在最近的Nimdzi调查中向我们提供公司数据的LSP。 你从名单上消失了吗?大概吧。好吧,我们来解决这个问题,好吗?我们鼓励任何想成为我们排名一部分的人在这里提供他们的数据。我们预计这一中端市场排名将在未来几年显著增长,因此请确保您将您的公司放在地图上! 中端市场的数字 数据显示,就增长而言,2022年对我们排名中的中端市场参与者来说是一个大杂烩。在59家公司中,26家报告了不同程度的增长,25家出现了负增长,两家公司的收入保持不变(六家公司没有报告2021年的收入,以便进行增长计算)。这表明与前100家最大的物流服务提供商相比有很大的差异,其中65家报告了不同程度的增长,35家公司出现了负增长。 就平均增长率而言,我们排名中的主要中端市场提供商在2022年以美元计算增长了6.4%,以报告货币计算增长了11.6%。这种差异并不奇怪。对于我们所有的全球排名和市场规模估计,就像其他行业一样,我们使用美国元作为共同点。因此,根据货币的不同,个别公司的增长数字在以当地货币计算时,与转换为美元的结果相比,可能会有很大差异。情况总是如此,但今年特别值得强调,因为许多世界货币在2022年相对强势的美国元大幅贬值。这对单个物流服务提供商和整个行业的增长产生了比往常更大的影响。 当我们将这些结果与业内前100家最大的LSP的结果进行比较时,也有显著的差异。在今年的Nimdzi 100排名中,以美国元计算,公司平均增长18.7%,以报告货币计算,平均增长26.5%。 尽管如此,主要中端市场提供商6.4%的平均增长率仍处于健康范围内,接近我们在Nimdzi 100市场分析中预测的未来几年全球市场整体复合年增长率(CAGR)7.0%。 按公司规模划分的增长 在按公司规模计算增长时,我们选择了中位数而不是平均值,以获得更准确的图像。 从结果来看,乍一看,员工人数较多的公司似乎名列前茅。当我们看下图时,拥有250至499名员工的公司取得了最好的增长结果(43.6%),其次是拥有500至999名员工的公司(14.3%)。然而,这造成了一个错误的印象,因为排名中只有两家公司属于250至499级,只有一家公司属于500至999级。这并不奇怪。在中型物流服务提供商中,绝大多数雇佣25至250名员工。再多就很少见了。 因此,如果我们考虑在这些范围内运营的大部分公司,结果会大不相同。在25至49岁、50至99岁和99至249岁的尺码等级中,2022年的中值增长率分别为0.6%、2.1%和-3.4%。 下图显示了2022年每个公司规模类别的增长中值,并比较了中型物流服务提供商的顶级中端市场提供商排名和全球最大物流服务提供商的Nimdzi 100排名的结果。 增长最快的10家中端市场LSP 以下是我们排名中增长最快的十家中端市场提供商(2021年至2022年间的收入增长,以美元计)。 十大最具生产力的中端市场LSP 看看我们排名中主要中端市场提供商的生产率,2022年每位员工的平均收入约为189,600美元。相比之下,2022年,全球前100家最大的物流服务提供商的人均收入约为229,300美元。 如果我们按收入等级考虑平均生产率,那么在我们的中端市场排名中,收入低于500万美元的LSP名列前茅(281,964美元)。其次是收入超过1000万美元(207,415美元)的公司。收入在500万至1000万美元之间的企业在2022年的平均生产率最低(147,124美元)。 考虑到公司规模,我们排名中最具生产力的10家公司中有6家雇佣的专业人员不到25人。其余四家公司有25至49名全职员工。 位置,位置,位置 按地域分布划分的增长 为了更好地了解中端市场的最大增长来自地理分布,我们根据总部所在的国家,绘制了一张按地区划分的LSP平均增长率图。 我们根据以美元表示的收入计算增长,使用美国国税局公布的2022年每天交易日对美国元的平均年汇率。正如本报告前面已经提到的,这意味着,对一些地区来说,货币波动扭曲了增长图景。如果我们以公司的当地货币按地区计算中端市场LSP的平均增长,那么通常不以美元报告的所有地区的百分比都有所增加:亚洲为14.8%(以美元计算为3.9.0%),欧洲为9.7%(以美元计算为0.3%),大洋洲为1.4%(以美元计算为-6.4%)。 按地理区域划分的LSP分布 在我们为此次排名确定的59家顶级中端市场提供商中,55.9%的总部位于欧洲,22.0%的总部位于北美。亚洲公司占地区分布的8.5%。大洋洲和南美洲各占我们名单上主要中端市场提供商的6.8%。总部设在非洲的公司没有代表。 趋势和业务挑战 虽然我们的Nimdzi 100排名只列出了世界上最大的100家LSP,但我们对Nimdzi 100的调查得到了来自世界各地各种规模的提供商的回答。仅考虑本排名中列出的LSP的回应,以下部分提供了这部分市场的几个主要趋势和挑战的快照 二零二三年主要业务挑战 在我们的顶级中端市场提供商排名中(并参加了调查)的公司中,超过90%的公司希望在2023年增加公司收入,这并不令人惊讶。之后,选择的前五大业务挑战是:实施新流程和技术(58.1%)、开发额外的服务产品(55.8%)、削减成本和优化流程(53.5%)、扩展到新的垂直行业(46.5%)以及管理价格压力(37.2%)。 这与Nimdzi 100调查的结果非常一致,该调查着眼于各种规模的供应商,有两个主要区别。当我们考虑各种规模的供应商的结果时,47.3%的供应商希望提高他们的品牌接受度和知名度,而在中端市场,只有32.6%的供应商有这种担忧。此外,在完整的调查样本中,42.6%的人担心人才的保留和获取,而在中端市场细分市场中,这一比例仅为34.9%。 全球事件的影响 尽管语言服务行业(正如我们喜欢说的)不受危机的影响,因为总是需要交流,但不可否认的事实是,个体企业仍然会有起有落。 最近对全球经济的冲击引发了劳动力市场的大规模重组,我们目前正在经历通货膨胀、货币波动、能源危机和科技行业的大规模裁员。 因此,对于今年的Nimdzi 100调查,我们想知道有多少LSP已经感受到了这些全球事件的影响,以及它可能如何影响他们的2023年战略。以下是我们的顶级中端市场提供商排名中的LSP的回复: 你感受到当前经济危机的影响了吗? 结果显示,超过三分之一的人已经感受到了通胀和经济压力的影响,另有40%的人正在考虑将潜在影响作为其2023年战略的一部分。只有大约24%的人完全没有受到影响。 与为各种规模的LSP收集的数据相比,结果略有不同。考虑到完整的Nimdzi 100数据集,五分之二的公司已经感受到了当前经济危机的影响,另外30%的公司正在为其2023年战略做准备,尽管尚未感受到影响。另有30%的人表示根本没有感觉到任何影响。 你的顾客在做什么? 当然,受到影响的不仅仅是LSP,每个人都是,买家也不例外。因此,我们询问了调查的受访者,到目前为止,他们的客户对此有何反应。仅考虑我们排名中主要中端市场提供商的反馈,结果显示大多数公司注意到客户减少了订单量(70.0%),另有23.3%的公司报告客户减少了本地化语言的数量。此外,40.0%的人表示,客户正在选择更便宜的机器生成的解决方案,而不是人工主导的服务。 这些结果与各种规模的LSP的完整数据集相似,但有一个显著的区别:在我们的顶级中端市场提供商排名中,33.3%的受访者表示,客户尚未对他们的业务做出任何改变,而在各种规模的提供商中,只有16%是这样。 你计划在2023年推出什么策略来抵消不断上升的通胀和经济压力? 最后,我们想知道我们行业的公司正在实施什么策略来应对2023年不断上升的通货膨胀和经济压力。结果显示,在顶级中端市场提供商中,报道最多的LSP行动方案是增加机器翻译的使用:50%的公司将使用这种节省成本的方法。其他受欢迎的解决方案包括提高客户价格(35.7%)和减少办公空间以节省成本(32.1%)。 除了这些增加收入和削减成本的策略,50.0%的公司报告说,他们将提高员工的工资,以帮助补偿当前经济环境下更高的生活成本。 21.4%计划裁员,28.6%希望要求供应商降低价格。 在完整的Nimdzi 100数据集中,这些结果再次朝着非常相似的方向发展。 结论 你计划在2023年推出什么策略来抵消不断上升的通胀和经济压力? 两件主要的事情。当谈到趋势和业务挑战时,我们排名中中型提供商的结果与我们考虑各种规模提供商的完整Nimdzi 100调查的结果基本一致。 然而,就增长而言,主要的中端市场提供商和前100名最大的物流服务提供商之间存在更明显的差距。在我们的排名中,近一半的中端市场提供商报告了2022年的正增长,相比之下,前100名中有近三分之二的中端市场提供商报告了正增长。尽管中端市场提供商的平均增长仍然健康,但也比前100名低12.3个百分点。假设中型提供商受到2022年经济挑战的影响更大,而大型提供商由于更多样化的客户组合和地理覆盖范围,能够更好地度过难关,这并非不合理。 总的来说,必须承认,这只是占语言服务行业大部分的大型中端市场的一个快照。我们可以预计这一排名在未来几年还会增长,这将使我们能够随着时间的推移描绘出一幅更准确的画面。 还不是排名的一部分?请务必在这里注册。

以上中文文本为机器翻译,存在不同程度偏差和错误,请理解并参考英文原文阅读。

阅读原文